Here’s another fine mess EBU’ve gotten us into…
Here’s another fine mess EBU’ve gotten us into…
As the EU elections begin around the continent, the European Broadcasting Union last night provided some voting drama of its own with the announcement – as already suspected by many fans – that the substitute jury result it calculated for Belarus in the grand final was completely wrong and has been revised. The result: Changes to the final scoreboard, with Sweden replacing Norway in the top five, and North Macedonia denied its rightful moment in the spotlight as the jury winner.
We have questions.
- How come this was allowed to happen in the first place, considering it was screamingly obvious to everyone watching on Saturday night that something weird was going on when the Belarusian votes went almost exclusively to countries at the bottom end of the scoreboard?
- At the very least, did the fact that Belarus’s 12 points went to a country that otherwise received no points from any other jury not raise any alerts, given that the entire point of the aggregated vote is that it reflects how other countries voted?
- What’s the point of the juries voting 24 hours before the public, on a completely different set of performances, if that time isn’t used to verify their results correctly?
- Is the idea of devising an artificial aggregated result to replace a disqualified jury really the best one anyway? Surely it’d be possible to either find a new set of people in Belarus to vote in the final, or to simply use an alternative jury – a representative sample from various parts of the continent, people from a non-participating country, former Eurovision winners, whatever. Anything seems preferable to adding points to the scoreboard that are literally made up.
- Since we now also know that multiple jurors messed up their individual rankings by putting their favourite song in last place and vice versa – and not for the first time – isn’t it time the EBU and Digame introduced more checks and balances, from on-site scrutineers to manual confirmations when the results are submitted by each country? How hard is it to get this right?
- How will this affect the betting markets? At time of writing, Betfair are digging in their heels when it comes to paying out on the revised results – which is understandable since, in theory, it also requires them to demand money back from those who won it e.g. on Norway finishing in the top five. However, the argument they’re using is that, under their terms and conditions, more than 72 hours have passed since the original result so the affected markets can’t be resettled. Since we all knew there was something fishy about the Belarusian jury result the instant it was announced, how come it’s taken the EBU so long to fess up?
- And perhaps most concerningly of all… what if this happens again, but next time the identity of the winner changes?
What a mess. It’s not quite enough to ruin the aftertaste of a fun and dramatic Eurovision grand final, but for the sake of the contest’s integrity, it really needs to be something that is never repeated.
Visit our Eurovision Chat!
0 Comments
Visit our Eurovision Chat!
Follow us:
RetroSongHunt 2004: Join us as we celebrate 20 years of #esc!
Our chat community celebrates its 20th anniversary on the first weekend of June – so what better way to celebrate than with a special chat event dedicated to national final songs from back when we began? Read all about it here!
Who will win the Eurovision Song Contest 2024? Our prediction for the final
Happy Eurovision – the big day has arrived! Tonight the grand final of ESC 2024 will be held in Malmö, Sweden. But who will hold the trophy at the end of the show? It’s time for our team’s predictions!
The View from Israel: Unforgettable
There’s one more night left for Eurovision 2024, and Shi is hoping we can all enjoy it a little.
Overthinking the 2024 grand final running order
As the dust settles on the second semi-final, Martin takes a look at what the producers have come up with for the ESC 2024 grand final running order and what – if anything – it might mean…
ESC 2024: The escgo! predictions for tonight’s semi-final 2
Let the team predictions continue! These are the songs that Felix, Shi and Martin think will qualify from tonight’s second semi-final of the 2024 Eurovision Song Contest.
The View from Israel: We rum-de-dum-dum-da
The View is back for Eurovision 2024! Different location, same overthinking – and now it’s time for the second semi-final.
ESC 2024: The escgo! predictions for tonight’s semi-final 1
It wouldn’t be Eurovision without some predictions from our team! These are the songs that Felix, Shi and Martin think will qualify from tonight’s first semi-final.
The View from Israel: Whеn the stars align then I’ll be thеre
The View is back for Eurovision 2024! Different location, same overthinking – starting with the first semi-final!
Gåte from Norway are the winners of ChatVote 2024!
The 20th annual edition of ChatVote is over, and the best song in the forthcoming Eurovision Song Contest is the one from…
ChatVote 2024 is launched! Once again: One Night. One Winner.
It’s time for the 20th edition of our legendary annual event. For our chat regulars, the lines are now open for you to submit your votes!
RetroSongHunt 2004: Join us as we celebrate 20 years of #esc!
Our chat community celebrates its 20th anniversary on the first weekend of June – so what better way to celebrate than with a special chat event dedicated to national final songs from back when we began? Read all about it here!
Who will win the Eurovision Song Contest 2024? Our prediction for the final
Happy Eurovision – the big day has arrived! Tonight the grand final of ESC 2024 will be held in Malmö, Sweden. But who will hold the trophy at the end of the show? It’s time for our team’s predictions!
The View from Israel: Unforgettable
There’s one more night left for Eurovision 2024, and Shi is hoping we can all enjoy it a little.
Overthinking the 2024 grand final running order
As the dust settles on the second semi-final, Martin takes a look at what the producers have come up with for the ESC 2024 grand final running order and what – if anything – it might mean…
escgo! on Twitter
0 Comments